Giants’ magical season ends on questionable check-swing call

San Francisco Giants’ Camilo Doval pitches against the Los Angeles Dodgers during the ninth inning of Game 5 of a baseball National League Division Series Thursday, Oct. 14, 2021, in San Francisco. (AP Photo/Jed Jacobsohn)

It’s not why the Giants lost, but it sure is a tough way to end it. 

With a runner on first, two outs and the Giants holding onto their playoff lives down a run, Wilmer Flores was called out on a questionable check-swing. The call ended San Francisco’s season, and ensured the Dodgers would move onto the NLCS. The call was not made by the home plate umpire, but rather by the first base ump upon appeal. 

“Super tough. You don’t want the game to end that way,” manager Gabe Kapler said postgame. “There are other reasons we didn’t win tonight’s baseball game,” he concluded. 

Adding insult to injury, it’s the second season in a row the Giants’ season has ended on a terrible call. In 2020, their playoff hopes were dashed on the final day with a questionable strike three call to Austin Slater by home plate umpire Rob Drake. The call ended a brutal day for Drake, one that cost the Giants 1.68 runs.

“It didn’t look like he went,” Ruf said of Thursday’s game-ending call. “A check swing earlier in the year helped us, too. It’s kind of funny how it comes down to those two events.”

With the San Francisco Giants season coming to a dramatic conclusion, the Morning Show with Nikki Medoro expresses their heartbreak over how the game ended on an umpire’s judgement call. Listen below.

Local News

KGO Events


Stay updated with KGO 810

Subscribe to KGO 810’s weekly eblast to get the latest information on local news, events, and exclusives from your favorite personalities.